Thursday, December 17, 2015

Regulating Taxi Service Aggregators
By Jayati Narain*

Those flying in or out of Kochi in the last few weeks, booking a Uber or Ola may have dealt with some odd requests by their taxi drivers. When being picked up, passengers are requested to meet their drivers outside the departures terminal, and when being dropped off they are warned they might have to take an auto for the last few kilometers, or complete the payment formalities before reaching the terminal.

Similar issues are being faced with those using these services to the train stations and to Lulu mall.

The reason behind these requests is the opposition by taxi unions, against such companies. In Kochi some cars operated by Uber were attacked by local taxi services (http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-kochi-drivers-of-services-like-uber-ola-attacked-by-local-taxi-drivers-2135757), as had happened in Mumbai a few moths before (http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/Scared-Uber-drivers-stay-off-roads-fearing-attacks/articleshow/48474969.cms). Taxi unions are protesting the unfair advantage that these companies enjoy in the market. While companies like Uber and Ola function as taxi operators and are direct competitors to traditional taxi services, they do not have to follow the same pricing mechanism as followed by traditional taxi services. This is due to the fact that at the operations end these companies do not identify themselves as taxi services, rather they identify as IT companies. The business model followed by these companies lead’s to a number issues regarding regulation and licensing.

These regulatory issues are present around the globe. With the growth of disruptive technologies and business models, legislators around the world are grappling with how to amend existing laws to make a place for these companies within their legal structure. The first step towards this has been the coining of the term transportation network companies (TNC). The term refers to the business model followed by these companies ‘an online-enabled platform that connects passengers and drivers using their personal and noncommercial vehicles.'Taxi service aggregators, such as Uber and Ola, provide a technological platform to bring together drivers and riders. The app acts as a way of connecting riders with the driver closest to them. The companies themselves, do not own any of the cars, nor do they consider the drivers employees. They identify themselves as facilitators, partnering with drivers to provide a service. While, at the consumer end they seem to be taxi-company with a convenient app, at the operations end they are very different. This model sets them apart from traditional transportation services, which require separate legislation. Clubbing all these services under the same legal framework is not feasible as their mode of operation, and treatment of drivers is completely different.
Developing the required legal framework has not been an easy task, both from the point of view of the TNC’s and the lawmakers. Each group has it’s own priorities and stakeholders to keep in mind, when framing any sort of regulating policy. This is complicated by the fact that is most countries transport is a state subject, requiring each state or city to frame it’s own laws, based on the specific local situation.

In India it is no different, with transport being a subject on the state list. However, a number of factors have brought these services to a national spotlight, leading to the central government getting involved in the framing of regulations. Issues involving passenger safety, regulating policies, registration and pricing mechanisms have all come together, sparking a national debate on the operation of TNC’s. This debate gets further complicated and confused, when looked at it within the global context, as a number of countries and cities are in the process of incorporating such services while keeping competing interests in mind.

The problems faced by TNC’s in India, can broadly be identified as those relating to safety regulations and the pricing mechanism. The central government has laid out the legal framework outlining regulations regarding TNC’s and has left it to state governments to work out the state specific laws, such as registration and monitoring.
After much back and forth in October 2015, the Central government issued an ‘Advisory for licensing, compliance and liability of on-demand information technology-based transportation platforms.’ The most significant aspect of this has been the distinction made between taxi companies and technology-based aggregators. While the advisory does allow for the business model followed by these companies, it also requires them to take greater accountability of the drivers engaged in the service and take greater safety precautions. While this step is encouraging, it still leaves these companies in a legal grey area. Currently they are placed under the domain of the Ministry of Road Transportation and Highways, coming under the Motor Vehicles Act. In order to operate in any city they are required register under this with the state government. In most state’s they have been required to get the same license as a radio taxi or city taxi service. The reason for this being that, even if these are technology companies they are in the transportation business and should be classified as any other transportation company.
Such a situation raises certain paradoxes in the operation of TNC’s. While the Centre recognizes them as separate from traditional taxi services, states require them to register as such. Even when they register as taxi services in various cities, they are not required to follow the same pricing scheme as traditional taxi and auto operators are. They are faced with opposition from both sides, wherein the state government’s do not recognize them as IT companies, and traditional services view them as having an unfair advantage in terms of price regulations. Much of the national debate surrounding TNC’s and the push back against them have combined these issues, hoping that they can both be resolved together.  But as the experience of various cities is showing, there is no one simple solution. Rather, both these issues- of registration and pricing need to be dealt with separately as each involves different stakeholders and has a different impact.

Within India, Kolkata has been the first city to deal with these issues separately. West Bengal has allowed these companies to register under the IT Act (2000) (http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2015-01-15/news/58109056_1_radio-taxi-scheme-web-based-taxi-aggregators-taxiforsure). They have separate laws regulating the service aggregator (IT Act) and the actual driver (Motor Vehicles Act). Such a move most closely matches the mode of operation of TNC’s themselves, which do not take responsibility for the driver unless they are specifically operating under the companies banner at the time of an incident.
The logic behind the pricing mechanism set up by the government for traditional transportation services is not something that can easily be found or broken up. This is an issue that is being faced by taxi operators around the world, leading to the recognition of the fact that these structures require a degree of revision. As several writers have argued, the regulation model for taxi companies is outdated, when facing the kind of market competition coming up now (http://www.newyorker.com/tech/elements/the-long-history-of-the-fight-against-uber).
In order to deal with the growing resentment by traditional transport services, TNC’s have tried to incorporate them into their operations. In Kolkata, the city’s iconic yellow taxies have started partnering with Ola (http://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/kolkata-s-yellow-cabs-now-on-ola-platform-115082800928_1.html), and in Chennai, Ola has been running an Ola auto service, partnering with auto-rickshaw operators, a service they are spreading to other cities as well. Such partnerships do not actually have a direct monetary benefit for the TNC, the operator or the consumer, but they have still been positively received. While the traditional operators still have to follow the same pricing structure, they have guaranteed riders and are viewed as embracing the shifting market trends. For customers paying a Rs.10 service charge, is worth the door-to-door by the meter service. For the TNC’s, it is an extension of their brand visibility, and technological interface.

Instances like this prove that there are viable solutions available to these problems. However, in order to achieve them the state government, the TNC’s and the traditional transport services need to work with a level of cooperation.
In Kochi, it is this cooperation that is missing at the moment.

While the state and city government have not openly taken sides, political parties are turning this into a contentious political issue. With parties backing the idea of traditional transport services coming up with a call taxi service, with an app of their own (http://scroll.in/article/765228/in-kerala-uber-and-ola-have-competition-from-the-states-biggest-business-house-the-cpim). Such a move may make their use more convenient, but it does not deal with the issue of pricing, which is where these companies are actually losing out. Unless, the state government tackles these issues directly, the antagonism between these services will continue to grow.
This can be done through following a model similar to that followed by the West Bengal government. By recognizing the TNC’s as IT companies, it makes it easier for the government to monitor and regulate them. As the TNC’s can no longer argue that they have been miscategorized. By partnering with TNC’s traditional operators are able to recapture some of the customers they have lost. This allows them to supplement their incomes, something the government set pricing scheme is limiting rather than facilitating. Until the government is ready to revise the pricing structure, they cannot blame consumers and drivers for moving to services, which are more convenient and affordable.

As customer behaviour is showing, even with the curbed movement, TNC’s are continuing to find passengers in the city. These companies are clearly here to stay, requiring the government to address the fundamental issues, rather then providing makeshift solutions.

*The author is the managing associate of CPPR- Centre for Urban Studies. Views are personal.


Unknown said...

good post

Unknown said...

Its very nice post. I have really enjoyed while reading your post. I want to say that there are many taxi service providers in the city that prices are vary greatly. One need to select the best taxi service provider for ride. In Mumbai Apnacabs is the new government licensed cab operator. Apnacabs charge government mandated rates and they are as per the meter reading. Know more about cabs in mumbai.

Anonymous said...

This post is really very nice.I loved the way of writing this article.
Airport cabs

Tempo traveller in Delhi NCR said...

Wow.. very good blog, Nice pictures and very informative..
Tempo traveller in delhi

Tempo traveller in Delhi NCR said...

Tempo traveller in gurgaon

Tempo traveller in noida

Tempo traveller in faridabad

Tempo traveller in ghaziabad

Admin said...

wow very good Awesome blog and pics with nice informations - tempo traveller in delhi / tempo traveller hire in delhi, tempo traveller on budget rates, india tour packages, tempo traveller hire tempo traveller in delhi at cheap and best price.. call us : 9211 204 827

Manikanta said...

Thanks for sharing this helpful information
silver service taxi melbourne
taxi booking melbourne airport
silver service cabs melbourne
melbourne airport taxi service
melbourne silver service 
silver service melbourne

Sonal Rajut said...

Get lowest Cabs fares in dehradun by RTS cabs for cabs & taxi service in dehradun. Ola cabs tariff in dehradun with its excellent on time service makes it the best cab to hire.

taxi service in dehradun

cabs in dehradun

Mike Willam said...

Very Nice post.. thanks for sharing it..

taxi service in Crawley

Unknown said...

Your blog is nice and it has some good content about those who are seeking to book tourist vehicle for their tour packages. Tempo Traveller is also a very good vehicle for group travel and you can book a tempo traveller by visit our website Tempo Traveller Hire Jaipur, Tempo Traveller Gurgaon, Tempo Traveller on Rent Chandigarh

Sonal Rajut said...

Call 24*7 Hour in this No. +91-9999992564, Taxi Service in dehradun, Cabs in dehradun,Drop Dehradun to Delhi, Cab in Rishikesh, Cheap Rate Taxi

taxi service in dehradun

cabs in dehradun

Cabs Available Now Call 7O151O9752 - Book taxi in Dehradun 24 Hour

Tempo Traveller Rental Company- Tempotravellerinncr.in said...

Wonderful blog with such a useful information, i really like it. There are many Tempo Traveller in Delhi ,Tempo Traveller in Gurgaon , Tempo Traveller on rent in Noida , Tempo Traveller on rent in Ghaziabad , Tempo Traveller on rent in Faridabad , Tempo Traveller in Noida for easy travel.


Thanks for sharing this informative article. Like to read more from you about tempo traveler in dehradun and what are their services and products.

Aasin Khan said...

After a long day, everyone wants to reach home at right time. So for this types of purposes, online cab booking option is best for this. Thanks for sharing this blogspot.
Taxi Service in Dehradun | Cab Service in Dehradun

Silver Service Taxi said...

Thanks for sharing this informative article.

Shivani said...

Indore cab service providing you a hassle-free, comfortable and affordable taxi cab service nearby your location to airport.

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing tour relative information. We are the best haridwar to delhi taxi

Our services is-
haridwar to gurgaon taxi service
haridwar to faridabad taxi service
haridwar to ghaziabad taxi service
rishikesh to noida taxi service
rishikesh to gurgaon taxi service
rishikesh to faridabad taxi service
rishikesh to ghaziabad taxi service
noida to haridwar taxi service

manutha said...

Wonderful blog!!! Even we didn’t know about all those things you’ve written in your blog i am manutha from Fox Travels

Haridwar Car Rental (Regd.) said...

exellent post given in this blog.. We are leading Best Travel Agents Haridwar.We have a wide range of cars in the offering from well known Innova to the latest Swift Dezire, Indigo, Tavera, Xylo, etc.

turbonuomalt said...

There has been a price hike of everything here in Vilnius and at this time buying a new car has no way a right deal. So, why to purchase a car, we guess you have not heard about our Automobiliu Nuoma (Car Rental) Services. Turbonuoma is the best in the business and offers all kinds of terms like short, long, day and even for celebrations. Get the services booked at the most high-flying rates that are 9 Euros per day plus there are many such discounts too.

Autonuoma | Automobiliu Nuoma | Automobiliu Nuoma Vilnius | Automobiliu Nuoma Vilniuje | Masinu Nuoma | Pigi Automobiliu Nuoma Vilniuje | Ilgalaike Automobiliu Nuoma

Melbourne Taxi said...

Nice Blog!
if you want to book Melbourne Airport Transfer,Melbourne Chauffeur Car,Melbourne Courier Service,Silver Service Taxi Melbourne so move towards us because we provide all services in very affordable prices.
Silver Service Cab Melbourne
Silver Service Taxi Melbourne Numbers
Silver Cab Melbourne
Melbourne Taxi Cab

Gurjap Tour and Travel said...

Brilliant and appreciable article. Hassle-free, comfortable and affordable taxi service in Chandigarh, kharar & nearby your location to travel within city or outstation across India.

Davinder Singh said...

Mohali cab service providing you a hassle-free, comfortable and affordable for sharing this blogger with us Best Taxi Service in Mohali

Tempo Traveller Rental Company- Tempotravellerinncr.in said...

Wonderful blog with such a useful information, i really like it. There are many Taxi rental services in Bangalore ,Car rental packages bangalore ,Book cab online in bangalore ,Cab rental Services in bangalore ,Cab Hire in bangalore ,Taxi Rental Company in Bangalore,Mini Bus rental in Bangalore,Tempo traveller rental in bangalore ,Tempo traveller hire in bangalore ,tempo traveller rental bangalore ,tempo traveller rental company in bangalore ,Tempo traveller for outstation bangalore ,Travel agents in bangalore  for easy travel.

My Himachal News said...

Such a nice information
Cab in Amritsar
Taxi in Amritsar
Amritsar taxi
Book taxi in Amritsar
cab service in Amritsar

fast car booking said...

Wow!!! It seems a very beautiful place.... Thanks for sharing this article...Very nice information for traveler ..thanks a lot for sharing this information.Thanks a lot for giving proper tourist knowledge and share the different type of culture related to different places. Fast Car Booking is one of the leading Delhi to haridwar Taxi and Cab Services provider in Delhi to all over.

fast car booking said...

Wow!!! It seems a very beautiful place.... Thanks for sharing this article...Very nice information for traveler ..thanks a lot for sharing this information.Thanks a lot for giving proper tourist knowledge and share the different type of culture related to different places. Fast Car Booking is one of the leading Delhi to Dehradun Taxi and Cab Services provider in Delhi to all over.

Davinder Singh said...

This blog is awesome, I read your article, each and every point is very useful for knowing about Best Taxi Service in Chandigarh, Best Taxi Service in Mohali, Best Taxi Service in Ambala Cantt

Manjot kaur said...

Nice blog. Thanks for sharing such valuable information with us. Keep sharing.

Taxi Service in Chandigarh
One Way Taxi Service Delhi to Chandigarh
Chandigarh to Delhi taxi service
Delhi to Chandigarh taxi service

Davinder Singh said...

This blog is awesome, I read your article, each and every point is very useful for knowing about Best Taxi Service in Chandigarh, Best Tax Service in Mohali, Best Taxi Service in Ambala Cantt

Manjot kaur said...

Great blog post. Keep it up.

One Way Chandigarh to Delhi Taxi Service
One Way Delhi to Chandigarh Taxi Service
Chandigarh to Delhi Taxi Service
Delhi to Chandigarh Taxi Service

gbairporttransfer said...

great post
Heathrow taxis provide very smart taxis service across London and airport transfer and taxis to all local cities.
Taxis in GB Airport Transfer-Heathrow Taxis Company provide taxis and minicab to all airports, seaport and railway station in London at affordable price also offers taxi
Gbairport transfer
Gbairport minicab
Gbairport taxis

Best Ooty Taxi - Taxi Services in Ooty said...

Amazing article ! It's very helpful and informative blog .Thanks for sharing beautiful picture and informative blog .I read your blog and it was exceptionally useful.Thanks for sharing.
Ooty Travels | Best Ooty Taxi

Tom said...

Great post.
millhill minicabs providing safe ride facilies for customer.minihill providing taxis,airport transfer and online booking minicabs through the all over the london city.
taxi services
millhill online booking
airport transfer

Cabs in Melbourne said...

Nice post thanks for sharing..
Melbourne Silver Taxi
Taxi To Melbourne Airport

Bhupinder Singh said...

Best Taxi Service in Chandigarh

Bhupinder Singh said...

Best Taxi Service in Chandigarh

Happy Travels said...

Happy Travels Provide Car Rental In Ahmedabad For Outstation Taxi, One Way Cab & Local Taxi Service. We provide Car Hire Service with fleet Of Swift Dezire, Innova, Innova Crysta, Tavera, Tempo Traveller 11 Seat, 12 Seat Maharaja, 14 Seat, 17 Seat. Also We are Offering Ahmedabad To Vadodara Taxi,Ahmedabad To Rajkot Taxi, Surat One Way Taxi Service.

Neha Uppal said...

Thanks for sharing such beautiful information with us. I hope you will share some more information about on demand taxi app development. Please keep sharing.

Silver Service Cab said...

I am glad to learn this valuable information.
Silver Service Cabs in Melbourne

Big Travels said...

thanks for sharing this article